The Best Pizza on Topsail Island and Surrounding Towns
When you think of Topsail Island, your mind might go straight to sandy beaches, fishing piers, and laid-back coastal charm. But after a long day in the sun, nothing hits the spot quite like a good pizza. From family-owned New York–style shops to artisanal wood-fired ovens, the towns surrounding Topsail—Sneads Ferry, Surf City, and Topsail Beach—offer plenty of excellent choices.
Sneads Ferry
DeNoia’s Pizzeria
A true hidden gem in Sneads Ferry, DeNoia’s is known for its hand-tossed New York–style pies. The dough is made fresh daily, the sauce is rich with flavor, and the slices are foldable just like they should be. Beyond pizza, the menu includes pasta dishes, subs, and daily specials. Locals especially appreciate their weekly discounts, including Wing Wednesdays and community nights with reduced pricing for seniors, first responders, and military families.
Michaelangelo’s Pizza & Subs
With a long-standing reputation across coastal North Carolina, Michaelangelo’s has been serving fresh dough and sauces for over 30 years. Their Sneads Ferry location is a reliable choice for a quick slice or a family pizza night. The menu extends to subs, salads, and Italian dinners, making it a versatile spot for groups with different cravings.
Surf City
Margherita Pizza Co.
For those seeking a more artisanal approach, Margherita Pizza Co. delivers some of the best wood-fired pizza in the region. Using organic and non-GMO ingredients, they create pizzas with authentic Italian flavors and a crisp, slightly charred crust. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, doubling as both a family spot and a casual date-night option. It’s no surprise locals have voted it among the best pizza and best dining experiences in the area.
Wildfire Pizza
Wildfire is a Surf City favorite for brick-oven pizzas that cook in just 184 seconds. Known for their fresh dough and quick turnaround, it’s a great choice if you’re looking for something fast without sacrificing quality. Their delivery service makes it especially convenient for vacationers staying on the island.
Santorini Bistro
While Santorini is best known for its Greek specialties, the pizza holds its own. With a Mediterranean influence, you’ll find toppings that go beyond the basics, along with pasta dishes and a full bar. It’s a good pick if you want pizza but others in your group are leaning toward gyros or seafood pasta.
Topsail Beach
Max’s Pizza
No list of Topsail pizza would be complete without Max’s. Open since 1984, this long-time institution is a staple for both locals and visitors. Known for its crispy crust, generous toppings, and classic family-friendly vibe, Max’s has been serving loyal fans for decades. It’s the kind of place that feels like a tradition every time you stop by.
A Slice of Coastal Flavor
Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite after surfing in Surf City, winding down with family in Sneads Ferry, or ending a beach day in Topsail Beach, there’s no shortage of excellent pizza. Each spot offers its own flavor of hospitality—from DeNoia’s classic New York style to Margherita’s wood-fired creations and Max’s tried-and-true tradition.
This article is part of A Complete Guide to Dining on Topsail Island, which provides an island-wide overview of restaurants, dining districts, cuisine types, and local food experiences.
About the Author
Written by J.L. Wells, a longtime Topsail Island resident with firsthand experience exploring the island’s beaches, restaurants, local businesses, coastal activities, and community events throughout the year. Drawing on lived local knowledge, J.L. Wells reports on local happenings and provides practical insight to help readers understand what Topsail Island offers visitors and residents alike.